Appearance: Looks like what a beer should look like. The color of a dark honey—gold orange. Nice thick creamy almost-white head.
Smell: Clean, sweet, caramel, honey, and a bit—just a bit—fruity. Mature hops.
Taste: Bitter but not harsh; malty but not sweet. Very nice. Whole grain. Slightly bready—biscuit. Dough. Hops are smooth and clean and not at all astringent. Almost a creamy character.
Mouthfeel: Very good—medium-bodied, a buttery hop twang (bitterness) that bites the sides of your tongue.
Overall, this is an excellent beer, almost perfect. I’d go so far as to say that this is what a beer should be. In fact, when I just hold the (generic) concept of "beer" in my head, this is the beer that I’m imagining. It’s that good.