I even had a bit of the Dagoba dark chocolate they sent with this beer; they pair well together and overall, I really enjoyed it.
Appearance: Black, dirty motor oil-colored with a nice dense froth of foam (though I didn’t pour it rigorously enough to be overly thick). Opaque and quite attractive.
Smell: "Roast" is an apt description—it’s full of coffee and roasted barley and some deep bittersweet chocolate notes. Almost a coffee liqueur thing going on.
Taste: Black as night and tastes every bit of it. "Char" notes—in a good way—make me think "burnt wood"; French roast black coffee (Turkish?); lots of black malts; a touch smoky. Fairly dry even as it has a silky texture. Very "roasty" here too.
Mouthfeel: Full-bodied, well attenuated, a silky smooth feel overlaying other subtleties. Finishes dry with a coffee aftertaste.
Overall: Very good, very rich and lots of roasted goodness happening here. The more I drink, the more I notice the long, dry finish—it’s fairly pronounced and enhances the coffee character. Holy smokes, it accompanies the Dagoba dark chocolate really well.
On BeerAdvocate, it scores an overall grade of A-. (RateBeer is still down.)